Ed: Has this been helpful for you guys? Do you feel satisfied?

Rich: Yeah, it's got a movement

Gary: Good quick simple solutions, we hope — We appreciate the the opportunity.

Rich: Yeah, these are easy to implement. Everything's easy to implement. It's just about doing it.

Ed: So, would that be if you guys are to recommend me would be a yes or would it be a maybe or maybe a no?

Gary: Now it's a yes. It'll be a yes.

Rich: Yeah, absolutely.

Ed: Thank you very much. Awesome. If you need anything else, you have my email. Just feel free to let me know

https://youtu.be/7_vjAjt6nro?si=cFA18hSFgrqwP09A

Case Study: Membership Growth & Fundraising Strategy for Community Service Organization

Targeted Facebook Advertising and Multi-Platform Scheduling to Diversify Age Demographics and Expand Early Literacy Program Reach

Client Overview

<aside> 📸

Project Snapshot

</aside>

<aside> ⚠️

The Challenge

</aside>

<aside>

The Challenge

Gary and Rich represented the classic civic organization paradox: established community presence with proven impact (10,000 children receiving monthly books) but struggling to translate offline credibility into digital reach and demographic diversification. They posted regularly to social media, managed large email lists, and understood their service area precisely—yet couldn't break through to younger demographics or systematically expand their literacy program beyond current 10,000 enrollments toward the 35,000-child county potential.

"We have a Facebook and an X account, and we post regularly—Doug makes comments every week when I make a post, so that helps," Gary explained. "But honestly, if we can't help ourselves, the segmentation won't help. I would have to have a very specific sit-down with some of our younger members and try to engage them to share into their groups."

This opening revealed the underlying frustration: organic social media reach had plateaued despite consistent posting, and the solution—activating younger members' networks—required strategic framework the leadership lacked.

The Age Segmentation Challenge:

Rich articulated the core membership goal: "We're growing our membership, but we want to diversify, especially the age group. Right now we have 62 members—will be up to 63 in a week. That's actually a pretty decent sized club, but we'd really like to be at 100."

The organization understood their demographic problem (aging membership) and even identified the solution vector (younger members sharing into their networks) but lacked tactical execution plan.

"We have Dylan Bain and Russ Simmons and a few of the new younger ones," Gary noted. "We've got to find out even what platform they're on to begin with."

This revealed the knowledge gap: leadership didn't know which platforms younger demographics (and even their own younger members) actively used, making targeted outreach impossible.

The Organic Reach Plateau:

"We post regularly, but it's just not something that seems to engage people," Gary explained. "Doug makes comments every week when I make a post, and that helps, but if we honestly can't help ourselves, the segmentation won't help."

According to Hootsuite's 2023 Social Trends Report, organic reach on Facebook for pages averages 5.2% of followers—meaning a page with 500 followers reaches approximately 26 people per post without paid promotion. For civic organizations with older-skewing audiences, this drops further as younger demographics rarely follow traditional service club pages organically.

The Dolly Parton Imagination Library Scaling Challenge:

"Right now we've got 10,000 kids in the program, and we're authorized or responsible for a county that has 35,000 kids under 5 years old," Gary explained. "So finding a way to contact those families to get them involved, and finding organizations willing to fund us to pay for those books, is my biggest issue."

This presented dual challenge:

1. Family enrollment — reaching 25,000 additional eligible families with young children
2. Funding acquisition — replacing declining school district funding as Colorado education budgets tightened

The Matching Grant Leverage:

"The state of Colorado actually funds half—they are a matching grant for us," Gary noted. "Every dollar we can get, the state of Colorado matches that money."

This represented powerful fundraising tool (100% ROI via state match) underutilized in marketing messaging.

The Foundation Outreach Uncertainty:

"Previously, how have you been able to get sponsors?" I asked.

"Generally we've been getting the cities in our county, the school districts, and then other businesses and foundations," Gary replied. "We're just looking to expand the number of new foundations available to us because money from school districts is drying up really bad. Financing in the state—they're struggling to even match what they used to give us. So I have to find replacements."

Gary planned to target:

• Walmart stores in Adams County
• Target stores
• Barbara Bush Foundation
• Gates Foundation (uncertain if early education qualifies)

But lacked systematic strategy for foundation prospecting, proposal differentiation, or impact storytelling beyond standard grant application templates.

The Email List Underutilization:

"Do you guys have an email list?" I asked.

"Yes, a rather large one," Gary confirmed.

This represented untapped asset: large email database from fundraising events and community engagement never leveraged for Facebook lookalike audience targeting or systematic segmentation by donor behavior, event attendance, or geographic proximity.

The Platform Expansion Paralysis:

"What platforms are you guys on?" I asked.

"Just Facebook and X right now," Gary replied.

"Do you have the capacity to expand to more platforms?" I probed.

"Yes, we can," Gary confirmed. "That wouldn't be a problem if I use something like a scheduler. I used one years ago for business—I couldn't keep up with that either. Gotta sell insurance too, you know."

This revealed the classic volunteer capacity constraint: willingness to expand platforms existed, but manual posting across multiple channels wasn't sustainable given Gary's insurance business and volunteer time limitations.

</aside>

<aside> 💡

The Solution

</aside>

<aside>

The Solution

I conducted focused strategy consultation addressing the immediate membership diversification challenge via targeted Facebook advertising, then recommended specialized Catchafire project for the more technical foundation fundraising strategy.

The $5-$10 Facebook Ad Solution: Age-Targeted Membership Recruitment

Rather than prescribing complex organic growth tactics, I cut directly to the highest-ROI solution for reaching specific age demographics.

The Direct Recommendation:

"I think the most specific way to reach that audience is just probably to take like $5, $10, put it in Facebook ads and target by age range," I advised. "That's gonna be the fastest, most effective way for you to reach the specific audience."

"I know how to do that," Gary confirmed immediately, revealing technical capability existed—he simply hadn't connected Facebook Ads to membership recruitment strategy.

The Lookalike Audience Option:

"Do you guys have an email list?" I asked.

"Yes, a rather large one," Gary replied.

"You can create a lookalike audience from that and target similar people," I suggested. "Or just use the age range on Facebook to narrow down your audience. That's gonna be the most effective way."

The Strategic Decision:

"To do a lookalike, I would imagine most of our emails are similar demographics," Gary reasoned. "Some of these emails come from fundraisers that we've done, which generally generate the same people. It wouldn't hurt, but it's not really those we're targeting. It would be better just to do by age group."

"Yeah, I'd just do age group for sure," I confirmed.

The Business Knowledge Transfer:

"I do that in my business—I haven't thought about applying it to us," Gary said, experiencing the classic "aha moment" of transferring professional marketing skills to volunteer context. "Makes more sense that way."

This single recommendation—$5-$10 age-targeted Facebook ads—solved the membership diversification challenge Gary had framed as requiring complex member activation and platform discovery. Instead of:

• Identifying which platforms younger members use
• Convincing younger members to share posts
• Creating content that organically reaches younger demographics

The solution became:

• Spend $10
• Target Facebook users aged 25-40 in Westminster/metro Denver zip codes
• Run ad featuring community service impact + membership benefits

The Implementation Reality:

</aside>

<aside>

</aside>