<aside> 📸
</aside>
<aside>
<aside> ⚠️
</aside>
<aside>
Audrey and Lisa represented the classic nonprofit social media dilemma: competent execution of tactical posting (events, announcements, partner features) without strategic brand positioning foundation. They posted regularly, used decent imagery, included hashtags—but their social media failed to communicate the fundamental "what we do" and "why it matters" that converts casual scrollers into engaged community members.
"We have an Instagram, we have a Facebook, we have a newsletter, and I manage all of those things, but I also handle many other responsibilities," Audrey explained during our 60-minute consultation. "Sometimes our social media gets somewhat deprioritized. We would love someone who could review all of our social media platforms, provide insights on what's working well, identify areas for improvement, and possibly develop a framework to help us maintain a consistent content schedule that excites our community."
This framing revealed the underlying assumption: we need better content calendar and posting consistency. What they actually needed: fundamental brand messaging clarity before any calendar could be effective.
The "What Do You Do?" Crisis:
When I first reviewed Colorado Grain Chain's Instagram profile, I encountered immediate confusion.
"The first thing I noticed when I land on your page is I don't really understand what you guys are doing," I said during our screen-share consultation. "Your page needs to speak out when someone is checking it out. I see 'Colorado Grain Chain.' I see a post of a beer, someone here, a flyer—and I have no idea what you guys do."
The profile bio offered minimal clarity. The feed showed:
All competently designed. None explaining Colorado Grain Chain's actual function.
The Positioning Vacuum:
"Let's just go back to basics," I redirected mid-consultation. "What do you guys actually do? I don't mean to sound ignorant, but that's how we start so I can help you with social media structure."
Lisa provided the operational explanation: "We have business members—farmers, brewers, food makers. We have a website where they can connect and make sales to each other, and they can also advertise their products to people who would buy them. We also do a lot of education on different types of grain and nutrition and growing practices."
Functional. Accurate. Uninspiring.
"What's your unique positioning point?" I pressed. "What makes you stand out from random grains at supermarkets? What makes you more resonant? Is it that you're local? Is it that it's healthier? What is it that's special about you guys?"
"The thing is that we're local and that we connect all these businesses," Lisa replied.
The Messaging Failure:
"Then I think that really needs to come out on your social media, because just from the first couple of posts, it's not really coming out," I explained. "The local aspect and how you want to position yourself—I think that really needs to be looked into with regards to your marketing strategy and your messaging and positioning strategy."
This was the root problem: Colorado Grain Chain understood their operational model (member network facilitating grain commerce) but hadn't distilled it into emotionally resonant value proposition for social media audiences.
The Event-Heavy Content Problem:
Scrolling through the feed revealed another strategic weakness: overwhelming reliance on event promotion as primary content type.
"A lot of what it has been is promoting our events," Audrey confirmed. "That's pretty straightforward. But something we could use some work on is: when we don't have an event, how do we keep people engaged in our online community?"
The feed showed:
Between events: silence or generic partner re-shares.
According to Later's 2023 social media benchmarks, event-heavy accounts experience 40-60% engagement drop-off between promotional cycles because they haven't built sustained value delivery—audiences tune out after event ends.
The Text-Heavy Flyer Saturation:
Many posts featured event flyers—visually dense graphics with extensive text listing speakers, times, locations, sponsors.
"Your feed looks very populated—there's too much text," I noted. "Text here, text here, text here—there's just too much happening at once, especially with the flyers. The flyers are causing so much text to show up."
On mobile devices (where 90%+ of Instagram traffic occurs), these text-heavy graphics became illegible thumbnail clutter.
The Missing Call-to-Action Pattern:
Across posts, a consistent failure emerged: lack of clear next-step direction.
When reviewing an event poster: "What do I get out of this? Unless I know you guys personally or you've told me about it before, it doesn't compel me to sign up. What am I signing up for? What am I getting out of it?"
When examining partner features: "It doesn't really communicate anything. What do you want me to do with this? Do you want me to visit it? Do you want me to check it out? Did you just launch? Are you rebranding?"
Generic promotion without benefit articulation or action guidance.
The Anonymous Community Challenge:
Colorado Grain Chain operated in niche market (regional grain systems) without mainstream brand recognition. When promoting events with local industry speakers, they assumed name recognition that didn't exist.
Reviewing a panel event poster: "Are these guests big in the industry?" I asked.
"Some of them are—I mean it's a really local small industry," Audrey replied.
This created catch-22: speakers lacked celebrity draw to carry weak promotional copy, but promotional copy failed to communicate expertise/value speakers would deliver.
</aside>
<aside> 💡
</aside>
<aside>
I conducted comprehensive social media audit via 60-minute screen-share consultation, diagnosing brand positioning failures and providing tactical fixes across profile optimization, content strategy, messaging frameworks, and platform-specific recommendations.
The most immediate fix addressed the "what do you do?" confusion visible within 5 seconds of profile visit.
The Problem:
First-time visitors encountered feed showing disconnected imagery—beer photo, event flyer, product shot—with zero explanation of organizational purpose.
The Fix:
"You probably want to consider a pinned post that just shows what you guys do," I recommended. "I would say go for a carousel—a carousel with multiple images—and then in the description section, share what you guys do and how you want people to engage."
The Carousel Structure:
Lisa immediately grasped implementation: "Maybe it's a product with the co-brand on it."
"Yeah," Audrey confirmed, seeing connection to their branding goals.
This killed two birds: (1) explained organizational mission to new visitors, (2) showcased "Colorado Grown Grains" co-brand logo they wanted to promote.
Recommended Carousel Slides:
The Pin Strategy:
"Whenever someone visits my page, it will always be the page—it will always be the post at the top," I explained, demonstrating Instagram's pin function.
This transformed profile experience from "confusing scroll" to "immediate clarity" in one tactical change.
The Instagram bio failed to communicate organizational function.
"We also need to fix the bio—improve the bio, make it fun and exciting, and tell what we do," I advised. "Because right now I don't understand what you guys do."
The Bio Framework:
Instagram bios accommodate 150 characters. Colorado Grain Chain needed:
Before (Hypothetical Generic Version): Colorado Grain Chain
Building community around grains
After (Optimized Version): 🌾 Colorado's Local Grain Economy
</aside>
<aside>
</aside>
<aside>
</aside>
<aside>
</aside>
<aside> 🧠
</aside>
<aside>
</aside>